Deposit or advance payment when buying a horse in Poland - when can you get your money back?

Nov 5, 2026

The horse meets your expectations, you agree a price and the seller asks for a payment to reserve it until the veterinary examination. A few days later, the vet identifies concerning findings. You decide not to buy and are told that your money is forfeited. Is that necessarily correct? The answer depends primarily on what was agreed, the nature of the payment and why the transaction did not go ahead. Under Polish law, an earnest-money deposit (zadatek) and an advance payment (zaliczka) can have very different consequences.

This article concerns Polish law as at 2 November 2026. The Act of 23 April 1964 - Civil Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2026, item 795, as amended) is referred to below as the Polish Civil Code (k.c.).

Horse purchase deposits in Poland - what was agreed?

The first question is whether the seller merely agreed not to offer the horse to anyone else for a time, whether the parties entered into a preliminary agreement, or whether they had already concluded the sale itself. Calling the arrangement a ‘reservation’ does not settle this. A preliminary agreement under Article 389 § 1 k.c. creates an obligation to enter into a specified agreement in the future and should set out its essential terms.[1] For a sale, these will primarily identify the horse and the price or the method for determining it.

Messages exchanged before the bank transfer may also matter. The absence of a written agreement does not rule out a binding contract. Conversely, an advertisement and bank account details alone do not reveal every contractual term without the surrounding context. Article 65 k.c. requires consideration of the parties’ shared intention, the purpose of the agreement and the circumstances in which their statements were made.[2]

Deposit or advance payment - zadatek and zaliczka

A zaliczka is a payment towards the price. By itself, it does not entitle the seller to keep the money as a penalty for the buyer withdrawing. If it was paid towards a future sale and that sale is never concluded, it is generally repayable as an undue payment under Article 410 § 2 k.c. in conjunction with Article 405 k.c.[3] This does not mean that someone who breaches an earlier obligation can never be liable for the resulting loss.

A zadatek secures performance of an agreement. If the requirements of Article 394 § 1 k.c. are met, it may be retained or justify a claim for twice its amount. These statutory consequences apply unless the contract or an applicable custom provides otherwise.[4] A single word in a bank transfer reference is therefore not enough. The provisions explaining when the payment must be returned also need to be read.

If the purchase goes ahead, an advance payment counts towards the price. A cash zadatek is also normally credited towards the buyer’s payment under Article 394 § 2 k.c. If the price is PLN 40,000 and PLN 5,000 has already been paid, the remaining balance is therefore PLN 35,000, unless the parties agreed otherwise.

When can a deposit be kept, and when can you claim double?

Under the statutory rules on zadatek, the central issue is failure to perform the agreement for reasons for which the other party alone is responsible.[4] If the buyer refuses to perform a binding agreement without a contractual or statutory basis, the seller may be entitled to withdraw from it and retain the deposit. If the seller alone is responsible for non-performance, the buyer who paid the deposit has the corresponding right to withdraw and claim twice the amount.

For example, a double-deposit claim relating to PLN 5,000 amounts to PLN 10,000 in total. It includes repayment of the original PLN 5,000 and an additional PLN 5,000. Receiving a better offer does not release a seller from earlier commitments. Nevertheless, it is necessary to establish whether the agreement was actually breached, why this happened and whether the parties modified the deposit rules.

Exercising the rights in Article 394 § 1 k.c. requires withdrawal from the agreement. The provision allows this without setting an additional deadline, but a suitable declaration still has to be made to the other party.[4] Simply saying ‘I have changed my mind’ does not ensure that the right has been exercised properly. Nor is a zadatek automatically the price of an unrestricted right to walk away. That function may be served by a different arrangement, such as the withdrawal payment (odstępne) under Article 396 k.c.

When is only the original deposit returned?

An unsuccessful sale does not always mean forfeiture of the deposit or repayment of double its value. Article 394 § 3 k.c. requires the deposit to be returned when the agreement is terminated by mutual consent. The same applies where neither party, or both parties, are responsible for non-performance.[4] These statutory rules must be read alongside the particular agreement.

If the buyer and seller agree to end the transaction, they should record the amount to be repaid, the repayment deadline and how any costs will be settled. This can prevent a further dispute over whether the arrangement also covered the examination, transport or the horse’s stay at another yard.

The pre-purchase examination and repayment of the deposit

An unfavourable veterinary examination does not automatically entitle the buyer to recover a zadatek. What matters is what the parties agreed before payment, what qualities the seller represented the horse as having, the intended use and the significance of the finding. A withdrawal expressly permitted by the agreement following a specified examination result must be assessed differently from the buyer’s dissatisfaction where no such terms were agreed.

Before paying, agree who will examine the horse, by when, the scope of the examination and which findings allow the buyer to withdraw without losing the payment. Deadlines for supplying the records and refunding the money also matter. ‘Purchase subject to a satisfactory vetting’ may be insufficient if the parties understand ‘satisfactory’ differently.

Legally, these arrangements might take the form of a condition under Article 89 k.c. or a contractual right of withdrawal under Article 395 § 1 k.c. These are different mechanisms. A contractual right of withdrawal must specify the period within which it can be exercised. The wording should reflect the stage the transaction has reached. No single sentence will protect every purchase equally well.

Can the seller say that every payment is non-refundable?

Such a clause cannot be assessed separately from the agreement as a whole. Particular care is needed where a trader sells a horse to a consumer, meaning an individual buying for a purpose not directly connected with their business or professional activity under Article 22¹ k.c. In that situation, the unfair contract terms rules in Article 385¹ k.c. are relevant.[5]

A seller-drafted clause allowing the seller to retain every payment regardless of why the purchase fails may infringe the consumer’s interests. This does not mean that every zadatek in a consumer contract is unlawful. Its wording, the buyer’s actual influence over it and the circumstances in which the agreement was made need to be examined. Signing a standard form does not prove that all its terms were individually negotiated.[5]

A sale between private individuals does not attract consumer contract-term protection on that basis. However, this does not give the parties unlimited freedom to impose any terms they choose. The general limits on freedom of contract still apply. Where the buyer is a sole trader purchasing in connection with their business, the possible application of Article 385⁵ k.c. should also be checked. Describing the buyer as a ‘business’ does not settle the scope of protection.

Why do payment dates and limitation periods matter?

If the zadatek is to be transferred after the agreement is signed, its nature and payment deadline should be expressly agreed. A later transfer can still be a zadatek, but leaving this unclear makes its legal assessment harder.[4] Keep the agreement, transfer confirmation and complete correspondence, rather than a single screenshot.

A repayment deadline must be distinguished from a limitation period. Claims arising from a preliminary agreement, including claims concerning a zadatek stipulated in it, are generally subject to the one-year period in Article 390 § 3 k.c., running from the date on which the final agreement should have been concluded.[6] That period should not be applied to every payment connected with a proposed purchase.

In its resolution of 8 March 2007, III CZP 3/07, the Polish Supreme Court distinguished these claims from a claim for repayment of an amount paid towards a final agreement that was never concluded. The one-year period in Article 390 § 3 k.c. does not apply to that repayment claim.[3] The period must instead be determined under the appropriate rules, including Article 118 k.c. and Article 120 k.c. Calling a payment an advance is therefore no reason to postpone checking the documents.

What should you agree before transferring money?

The terms should identify the parties and the horse clearly, specify the price and explain the nature of the payment. They should also say what each party undertakes to do, when the purchase or performance of the sale is due, how the payment is credited and what happens if the transaction is abandoned. If the decision depends on a veterinary examination, agree its consequences before paying, rather than after receiving the result.

Other contractual provisions are discussed in my article on the horse sale agreement (Polish version). If a defect has already come to light after a private purchase, see the article on buying a horse from a private seller in Poland.

Are you about to make a payment, or is the seller refusing a refund? I can review the agreement, correspondence and transfer confirmation, assess what was agreed and help prepare suitable terms before a purchase. You can describe the situation and attach documents using the contact form.

Legal basis: Act of 23 April 1964 - Polish Civil Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2026, item 795, as amended).

Author: Witold Łukasik, lawyer. This article is for information only and does not constitute legal advice. An assessment of a specific matter requires its documents and circumstances to be examined.

Sources and notes

  1. A. Zbiegień-Turzańska, in W. Borysiak (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, 36th ed., 2026, commentary on Article 389 k.c., particularly the distinction between a preliminary agreement and a final agreement.
  2. P. Sobolewski, in W. Borysiak (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, 36th ed., 2026, commentary on Article 65 k.c.
  3. Polish Supreme Court resolution of 8 March 2007, III CZP 3/07, OSNC 2008, no. 2, item 15. Resolution and reasons. The case concerned a proposed sale of shares. It is cited for the general distinction between an advance payment and claims under a preliminary agreement, not as a horse-related case.
  4. A. Zbiegień-Turzańska, in W. Borysiak (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, 36th ed., 2026, commentary on Article 394 k.c., concerning zadatek and zaliczka, the time of payment, withdrawal and repayment.
  5. P. Mikłaszewicz, in W. Borysiak (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, 36th ed., 2026, commentaries on Article 385¹ k.c. and Article 385³ k.c.
  6. A. Zbiegień-Turzańska, in W. Borysiak (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, 36th ed., 2026, commentary on Article 390 k.c., section on limitation periods.

Illustrative photograph: Man Dy / Pexels. Used under the Pexels licence.